The False Witness of a “Straw Man”

In Exodus 20:16 we are given the 9th Commandment: “You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor.” This verse entails numerous applications, but one of them includes purposefully misrepresenting the position of another. It is not uncommon for opponents of a given position to construct what has come to be known as a “straw man”: a caricature of the opponents’ position which does not accurately represent their views, but which is relatively easy to refute.

While the “straw man” makes an easy target, we should realize that not accurately representing the position of the opponent is bearing false witness! That “straw man” you constructed is not what they believe! We need to beware of this temptation. Just because you oppose the philosophy or actions of a person or group, does not justify ANY means to discredit them. Christians do not follow the philosophy of “the end justifies the means.” This applies to debates over theology (the contemporary debate over Calvinism is a prime example!) and yes, even politics. We are to conduct even our arguments with righteousness and honor – and that means representing even those who oppose us with fairness and integrity.

Unknown's avatar

About Shawn Thomas

My blog, shawnethomas.com, features the text of my sermons, book reviews, family life experiences -- as well as a brief overview of the Lifeway "Explore the Bible" lesson for Southern Baptist Sunday School teachers.
This entry was posted in Devotions/Bible Studies. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to The False Witness of a “Straw Man”

  1. oloryn's avatar oloryn says:

    I’ve noticed that a lot of people practically take the position that once they’ve “convicted” someone of being wrong on something, it is no longer necessary to be careful about being truthful about them. At that point they feel free to attribute any motivation or belief that occurs to their imagination to the “guilty” party. One of my responses to this is that given “you shall know the truth, and the truth shall set you free”, if you’re willing to be cavalier about the actual truth (not just what you imagine is the truth) about someone else, you’re likely disqualifying yourself from being a vehicle to set that person free.

  2. Pingback: Straw Man Fallacy | Devious Tactics

Leave a comment